Mercedes-AMG Petronas Motorsport team set to fire up at Monza
Hi, Bob Aldons, The Car Guy, with a story courtesy of the Mercedes-AMG Petronas Motorsport team prior to this weekend’s Formula 1 race at the famous Italian GP circuit at Monza.
And this is all about braking. Now, as we know from our own experiences with braking, we should break slowly and increase pressure as we plan to stop.
Not so with Lewis Hamilton and Valtteri Botas. In a Formula 1 machine they’re on the accelerator pedal until they hit their braking point and then it’s smashing the brake pedal to the floor to navigate the corner – generally.
You’re sure to have seen the passing under braking and that’s where the more skilful drivers (Daniel Ricciardo for example) brake late to pass. Nerves of steel for sure. So let’s hear what the experts have to say about braking and particularly around the Monza circuit.
Hitting the Brakes in Monza
Monza is famous for its high-speed nature, with its long straights and only a limited number of corners. This makes every turn – and every time the drivers hit the brakes – even more important.
Why is braking important?
Before a Formula One car turns into a corner, it needs to be slowed down, so braking is the first part of any corner phase. So if a driver doesn’t get the braking right, he will usually mess up the entire corner and lose valuable time.
From an engineering point of view, a corner presents a bit of a contradiction. Under braking, the car should be as stable as possible, requiring the least amount of driver steering correction. However, once you reach the turning point of the corner, you want a car with a great turning capability that is very reactive to steering input.
Ideal straight-line braking stability would require a rather numb front end with lots of front downforce; however, that would make turning into the corner very difficult. So the engineers have to fine-tune the car and try to find the right balance. The two main areas they will look at for this compromise are aerodynamics – mostly the front wing – and the suspension set-up.
What makes braking in Monza so important?
Monza is a relatively fast track, so the drivers have to slow down their cars from very high speeds. Additionally, they will be running the lowest downforce configuration of the year, which makes braking at the Autodromo Nazionale Monza even more tricky.
Most of the track in Monza is wide open throttle and only limited by the drag characteristics of the car and the performance of the Power Unit, making the eleven corners of the circuit particularly important, as that’s where a driver can easily gain or lose a chunk of lap time over his competitors.
That is especially true for the two major braking events at the Autodromo – the Variante del Rettifilo (Turn 1 and 2) and the Variante della Roggia (Turn 4 and 5). On his fastest race lap in 2017 (Lap 50), Lewis was going over 330 km/h before he hit the brakes going into Turn 1, shedding over 260 km/h and slowing down to under 70 km/h.
On the straight before Turn 4, he was doing 310 km/h and decelerated to under 110 km/h. At both events, the drivers will easily pull over 4G. To put this in comparison: a high-performance road car with special tyres can achieve a little over 1G.
The heavy braking is not just demanding for drivers, but also for the brakes themselves: On the long straights, brake discs will cool down to about 200 degrees Celsius. But when the driver hits the brakes, temperatures will rise to over 1,000 degrees within a second. Managing the brake temperatures is, therefore, an important job of an F1 driver as brakes that are too hot are prone to fading and might cause reliability issues.
How similar are road cars and F1 cars when it comes to braking?
The short answer is not very similar at all. Formula One cars have lots of downforce available – and the amount of downforce increases the faster they drive. The more downforce the car produces, the higher the grip level – which means that the cars have more stopping potential at high speeds than they have at low speeds.
This makes braking an F1 car quite challenging as the grip levels change. While, for example, it would be quite difficult to lock the wheels under braking when the car is going at speeds of over 300 km/h, it is in fact quite easy to do so at 60 km/h. So F1 drivers have to brake very hard at the start of braking when they have the most stopping potential and then fade it as they get towards the turning phase of the corner to prevent potential lockups.
But that’s not the only difference between an F1 car and a road car when it comes to braking. F1 cars also use brake migration – a dynamic change of the brake balance as a function of the brake pressure. Here’s how it works: Under braking, there’s a weight transfer happening in the car.
It’s the same kind of weight transfer you can experience when you stop any vehicle abruptly – in a road car, you’re thrown into your seat belt, on the London Tube you might end up on your neighbour’s lap. F1 cars use this kind of weight transfer to their advantage and shift the brake bias towards the front of the car when the drivers first hit the brakes.
When they then slowly come off the brakes to prevent locking up, the weight transfer to the front is reduced. At that point, the brake power is migrated rearwards – by how much depends on the track and the type of corner. Drivers can adjust the brake migration on a corner-by-corner basis through a rotary switch on their steering wheel.
Just before the turning point, you could move the brake bias almost entirely to the rear to give the car a bit of oversteer, allowing it to turn more quickly – similar to the effect of pulling the handbrake in a road car.
How did hybrid technology and brake-by-wire systems change braking on an F1 car?
Hybrid engines have given the engineers the chance to harvest kinetic energy under braking and use that energy to propel the car forwards again when the driver accelerates. But in addition to harvesting energy, the introduction of hybrids and brake-by-wire systems gave the engineers another avenue to fine-tune the car and further advance braking by improving brake migration.
In the pre-hybrid era, the teams used mechanical systems to change brake balance through a corner or a braking event. To quickly adjust the brake balance between corners, they would use a hydraulic system. Both of these functions can now be operated with a switch on the steering wheel – in fact, a total of five buttons and rotary switches on the wheel.
This means that the drivers can access those functions much faster. Another benefit of the system is that the engineers can compensate for how the power unit behaves under braking and downshifting. Every time the driver opens the clutch, he loses the engine braking.
In the pre-hybrid era, that would mean that there were sudden shifts in brake balance and brake power every time the clutch would open and close. Today, the cars can counteract that with a little spike of brake pressure every time the car loses the engine braking. This means that the rear brake torque is more continuous, allowing the driver to operate closer to the peak of the tyre slip.
How hard do F1 drivers hit the brakes? How much pressure do they apply to the brake pedals?
Generally speaking Formula One drivers generate a lot of brake pressure. When they hit the brakes, they basically stand up on the brake pedal. As they brake at 4G, they will apply roughly four times their body weight to the pedal.
At the same time brakes – like almost everything else in an F1 car – are highly customisable and depend very much on driver preferences. The brake pedal can be adjusted to how hard a driver usually hits the brakes as it works as a lever upon the master brake cylinder.
So if a driver feels that he has not enough power in his legs, the brake pedal can be manipulated to generate peak pressures more easily; however, this would also mean that the pedal will travel further. For that reason, training his legs is part of every driver’s fitness programme.
How much does the braking point vary on a lap-by-lap basis? Are F1 drivers able to hit the brakes at the same time on every lap?
The ideal braking point will change over the course of the race – depending on fuel loads, compound choice, tyre degradation and how much the drivers have to manage the tyres. So the drivers have to vary their braking during the race, keeping in mind all the parameters that influence it.
In qualifying, the braking points stay more or less the same as the car goes out on similar amounts of fuel and on fresh rubber. If you look at telemetry overlays from qualifying, you can appreciate that the drivers are able to repeatedly hit the brakes at roughly the same spot.
Usually, they will brake within a couple of metres or less; five or six metres is a significant difference. This is all the more impressive if you consider that a car that’s going 330 km/h travels almost 92 metres in a single second. So being able to hit the perfect braking point is a matter of fractions of a second.
How do drivers find the ideal braking points?
Drivers determine the ideal points for braking over the course of the weekend. They will start conservatively, braking early and allowing for a small margin of error. As the track builds up grip, they will push the braking points deeper and deeper towards the corner, changing it by a few meters at a time and pushing it all the way to the limit.
But there’s always one braking point that is extremely tricky to get exactly right: braking into Turn 1 on the opening lap of the race. There’s no practice on Sundays, so drivers have to estimate the grip levels as best as they can from the few laps to grid they do before the race. To make things more challenging, the brakes will be cold, making it even harder to estimate where to brake.
Additionally, the other drivers might be willing to take a bit more risk going into Turn 1 as the field is bunched up and one can easily gain a position, so you don’t want to brake early as you might be overtaken. All those circumstances make it very difficult to determine when to brake into Turn 1.
However, the drivers do get a bit of help from their engineers who will suggest brake balance and brake migration settings to them based on historical data.
Bob Aldons is the owner and founder of The Car Guy, reviewing cars, reporting on Car Industry Matters, Car Tech and the world at large. He’s spent the last forty years immersed in the automotive industry from salesman to the owner of a 7 brand multi-franchise dealership. Bob knows cars.
If you’re hunting around for a great price on your next new car, you should call the auto expert, Bob Aldons from Car Business. My company, a car Broker, Car Buyers Agent or Car Buyers Advocate based on the north side of Brisbane, will return your inquiry within 24 hours and make the process of buying a new car easy and stress-free.
Are you tired of salesperson tricks? I protect you from the pressure exerted by car dealer’s salespeople. There isn’t any obligation – just a pretty significant saving.
You’re where? Seriously, my services are available for you in any Australian state and territory: from Darwin to Hobart, Cairns to Perth. Car Broker Brisbane, Sydney, Melbourne, Adelaide, Perth, Hobart, and Darwin – I’m available when you need me to be.
Whether you’re a small fleet or a large national fleet, Car Business will go to work and get that price down. Lower new car prices are my goal. So you’ll get the best prices from us rather than hoping you can help yourself.
If I can’t get you the best new car price, better than you can get yourself from a car dealer, we won’t charge you any fee. No Saving, No Fee. – that’s what you should expect from a car buying expert.
Car Business WILL save you money on your next new car purchase – guaranteed
The Australian Road Safety Foundation is a not-for-profit organization whose charter is to reduce serious accidents on our roads through training and education. Car Business donates to the ARSF for every car we sell. If you’d like to support this worthwhile foundation, donate to the cause, become a member today or just buy your next new car from Car Business